Every generation of consumers has different needs. Younger insurance buyers do not want to shop for insurance in the same ways their parents and grandparents did. These consumers grew up online and have very different expectations and needs than prior generations. Insurance agents must consider the best ways to reach these consumers, and while it may seem that digital first is the answer, there is more nuance to the challenge of connecting with younger insurance buyers.
Read on to learn why independent agents remain a critical piece of the insurance puzzle for younger insurance buyers and how the relationship is changing.
Digital Convenience With Human Service
While it is true that digital convenience matters significantly to younger insurance buyers, that isn’t the whole picture. Valuing a digital first experience does not mean these consumers don’t also value their insurance agent. It does, however, change the relationship and expectations.
When considering what younger consumers value from digital interactions, it is often the speed, transparency, accessibility, self-directed nature, and convenience of these experiences that is most valued. However, technology alone cannot provide the personalized advice, proactive guidance, and venue-based experience grounded with an in-depth understanding of the individual policyholder’s risk that agents can.
In the past, an insurance purchase may have begun when a prospect called an agent with questions or to obtain a quote. For younger insurance buyers, the interaction may begin long before they contact an agent. Consumers search for options, use online quoting systems, ask their AI for advice, read online reviews, visit carrier websites, and compare options using online aggregators. By the time they reach out to an agent, this prospect has likely formed opinions about their coverage needs and price tolerance.
This changes the role of the independent agent from being the primary source of information to helping consumers decipher the details they have learned and determine which pieces of data are credible and relevant to them.
Younger insurance buyers may not need help finding a quote, but they do need an agent to explain whether they should increase their deductible based on their individual financial goals and circumstances or why selecting the state-minimum limits may leave their assets exposed.
Information is abundantly available, which means having an agent to explain context remains important even in a digital-first world.
How to Best Support Younger Insurance Buyers
Here are five steps to supporting younger insurance buyers and building a long-lasting relationship:
Make the first digital interaction easy. Almost 60% of Gen Z consumers search through social platforms, so agents can assume the prospect will research them and their agency first. Make sure websites are intuitive and updated. Offer digital forms and contact options and make transitions between chatbots and human staff seamless. The goal is to make reaching an agent a frictionless process.
Communicate on the policyholder’s terms. Respond quickly to consumer requests and use the same format as the consumer. For example, if a prospect emails or sends a digital message through an agent’s website, responding via phone call may not be welcome. Digital-first consumers expect quick responses and asynchronous communication.
Provide context, not jargon. Consumers can find basic information, definitions, and reviews easily. They need agents to explain context, remove incorrect assumptions, and level-set about pricing and coverage. Agents can help explain what would happen if a policyholder with low limits caused a multi-vehicle loss or whether a renter’s policy has sufficient coverage for the policyholder’s property. Agents should translate coverage into decisions that make sense based on the policyholder’s needs.
Be transparent about trade-offs. Younger insurance buyers may be looking for a cost-effective option. Agents can help explain the trade-offs, benefits, and opportunities of different coverage levels and help consumers find the right combination of coverage and retained risk for their individual circumstances.
Technology can automate transactions and agents can provide guidance. Part of working with digital-first consumers is providing the right level of digital experience and human guidance. An important part of an agent’s role is advising a policyholder and answering questions, and technology can automate routine transactions like payments, reminders, and status updates. Difficult renewals, a first-home purchase, or support after a major life change are opportunities for agents to build stronger relationships with policyholders and provide the support only agents can offer.
Try these five steps when working with younger insurance buyers. Agents that successfully combine digital convenience with the expertise of an agent offer more value than a strictly digital transaction or traditional agency can replicate. This may be the strongest advantage independent agents have when working with younger insurance buyers.
Become a Member of the American Agents Alliance to Learn More
Members of the American Agents Alliance enjoy access to exclusive member benefits, including valuable opportunities to save and learn. Become a member today!
External Links:
- https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20260826145480/en/New-MAX-Report-Separates-True-Gen-Z-Behaviors-From-Life-Stage-Trends
- https://www.forbes.com/councils/forbesbusinessdevelopmentcouncil/2024/03/15/the-rise-of-consumer-centric-digital-first-strategies/


